- Brilliant Earth vs Ritani: Which Jewelry Brand Should You Choose? - November 20, 2026
- Where to Buy Gemstone Engagement Rings - November 1, 2026
- Brilliant Earth vs KAY Jewelers - September 29, 2026
Choosing an engagement ring or special piece of jewelry is an exciting milestone. With a little guidance the process can be smoother, especially if it’s your first time shopping and you’re still deciding where to start.
Jewelry is a meaningful and lasting investment, it pays to shop with confidence. One way to do this is to compare different companies. Brilliant Earth and Ritani are large companies in the online diamond sales industry. Both sell fine jewelry, engagement and wedding rings, loose diamonds, and gemstones. The right choice depends on your priorities, but a detailed comparison will help you shop as an informed buyer.
Comparison Chart

|
Feature |
Brilliant Earth |
Ritani |
|
Diamonds |
Natural and lab grown diamonds |
Natural and lab grown diamonds. |
|
Gemstones |
Natural and lab grown gemstones |
Natural gemstones only |
|
Ring Setting Pricing |
From $650 |
From $880 |
|
Website |
High quality images and 360° videos of diamonds and rings. |
Low video quality on the cheapest diamonds. |
|
Grading Report |
Natural: GIA, IGI, and HRD Lab-grown: IGI, GIA, GCAL, HRD |
Natural: GIA and AGSL Lab-grown: AGSL, GCAL, GIA, IGI, HRD |
|
Shopping Experience |
Easy to navigate, very intuitive. Real diamond imagery and 360 videos |
Most of the photos of the rings are renders, not actual photos of the product. |
|
Customer Service |
Available 24/7 via chat, call, or text |
MON-THU: 9 a.m. – 10 p.m. |
|
Return Policy |
Free 30 day returns. |
Free 30 day returns. |
Brilliant Earth

Brilliant Earth was founded in 2005 with the aim of making the diamond industry more transparent, inclusive, and impactful. The brand is characterized by its pursuit of sustainability throughout its entire supply chain and Beyond Conflict Free Diamonds®, going beyond the Kimberly Process to ensure strict chain of custody protocols and fair labor practices. Brilliant Earth first introduced lab-grown diamonds in 2012, becoming one of the pioneers in using these types of diamonds. They work with repurposed metals and aim to achieve zero gas emissions by 2030. Brilliant Earth operates over 40 showrooms across the United States.
Ritani

Ritani was founded in 1999 by a family of jewelers in New York. Its mission is to highlight craftsmanship and offer transparent prices. They follow the Kimberly process for ethical diamond sourcing standards. Ritani operates primarily as an online diamond marketplace. The brand offers a free in-person preview with a Diamond Pro for minimum orders of $1,500.
Main Features

Diamond Inventory
Both companies have large inventories. Brilliant Earth, currently lists over 400,000 diamonds, both natural and lab grown. Ritani has over 700,000 diamonds. These figures fluctuate daily, but the aim is to show you the scale of the inventory held by both brands. A significant difference in the colorless diamond inventory is that Brilliant Earth offers more diamond shapes than Ritani like the elongated cushion cut and old mine cut. Both shapes are available in both natural and lab grown diamonds. An elongated cushion cut is rectangular versus the traditional square cushion cut. It is shaped like a pillow, with gently rounded corners. The old mine cut is a shape commonly seen centuries ago and is the predecessor to the modern cushion and brilliant cuts. It also has slightly rounded corners, but is more square shaped.
EXPERT TIP: Remember to use the search filters to make your search easier. These figures represent the overall inventory—that is, with no filters applied. The results will narrow as you select filters for shape, price, carat, quality, grading reports and so on.
Gemstone Inventory
This is where the differences become more pronounced, as Ritani offers only natural gemstones—specifically rubies, sapphires, and emeralds. In contrast, Brilliant Earth offers natural and lab grown gemstones. They also have numerous varieties—such as moissanite, fancy diamonds, peridot, morganite, topaz, amethyst, and many more—in addition to the classics: ruby, emerald, and sapphire.
Pricing
Let’s start by comparing diamonds: at Brilliant Earth, lab-grown diamonds start at $140, while natural diamonds start at $160 and go up to $3,000,000. Ritani’s lab-grown diamonds start at $47; while natural diamonds range from $97 to $4,000,000. All these figures are estimates, as the inventory, and therefore the prices, changes every day.
Another important factor when looking for an engagement ring is the price of the setting—that is, the design that will hold the diamond. Brilliant Earth offers settings ranging from $650 to $6,090. Ritani offers ring settings ranging from $880 to $7,888.
Although Ritani’s prices are higher, they commonly have offers or discount codes; such as recently offering 30% off their settings. Conversely, Brilliant Earth prices are lower, and frequently have promotions, such as free gift with purchase. They also have exclusive gifts with purchase for university students from certain countries, as well as for first responders, teachers, military, and medical professionals.
Jewelry Collections and Designs

Collections are a jewelry company’s way of setting themselves apart from competitors. Brilliant Earth has exclusive collections that are unique to their company. Two collections known for their contribution and vibrancy are the Jane Goodall and Elizabeth Taylor collections.. The Jane Goodall collection is designed to celebrate and advance Dr. Goodall’s legacy, with 10% of net proceeds donated to the Jane Goodall Legacy Foundation. An exclusive partnership with the Elizabeth Taylor Estate is The Elizabeth Taylor Collection, spotlights three design motifs; True Blue, Bold Blossoms, and Gilded Glamour, the design motifs each inspired by a different facet of Elizabeth Taylor.
Ritani’s collections are more shape based. Their Boom by Daniele collection are all bold, playful designs. The Bezel set collection are pieces all categorized by thick bezels surrounding the stones. The WOLF collection is the one Ritani collection that’s completely different, because it isn’t jewelry. It’s a collaboration with WOLF, a family who has been handcrafting jewelry cases for five generations.
Another attribute that sets companies apart are their speciality gem cuts along with ring designs. For example Brilliant Earth is one of the only companies that offer both Old Mine and Elongated Cushion shape cut diamonds. Their rings come in modern designs that many jewelry companies tend to shy away from, especially in the engagement and wedding band industry. Ritani on the other hand has a collection of rings specially designed around the traditionally cut stone.
Customization
Brilliant Earth allows you to select the ring setting, specific metal, diamond, or gemstone, carat weight, and finally any additional stones or accent rings if applicable. You can see your finished design in a 3D rendering and on your hand with virtual try on. If you want to create a fully custom design from scratch, you will need to contact the design team. Their fully custom design service takes 4 to 6 weeks, with prices starting at $2,000.
With Ritani, you can choose the setting and then the diamond you prefer, but there is also the option to use their design software. This allows you to customize parts of the ring to your liking and generates a rendering as you select your options, so you can see how the ring takes shape based on the options you choose. You start with the diamond shape, then the head (prong, halo, or vintage style), followed by the ring band, and finally the engraving. Once these aspects are decided, the next step is to choose the diamond itself. In the end, you’ll see the final price of the ring.
Online Shopping Experience
Brilliant Earth features 360 degree videos of its diamonds, which is essential for assessing quality; they also provide an image showing the diamond’s size relative to a hand, which is incredibly helpful when shopping a ring online.
Ritani also offers 360 degree videos, but personally, I find the quality of some diamonds to be lower. It tends to be the cheaper diamonds with the lowest carat weight. This could be because they lack sharpness. This is a main difference compared to Brilliant Earth. For some, video quality is the most important factor when making a purchase.
EXPERT TIP: When buying a diamond, understand the photo and video you are shown are of that specific diamond or a sample image or rendering.
Grading Reports

When buying a diamond, especially larger than 0.5 carats, I recommend choosing one that comes with a certificate. This indicates the diamond’s quality and verifies whether it is natural or lab-grown. The most important certificates come from the GIA (Gemological Institute of America) and IGI (the International Gemological Institute). Both Brilliant Earth and Ritani offer grading reports from these laboratories.
EXPERT TIP: Independent laboratories have experts trained to provide an objective scientific analysis of the diamond’s identity, quality, and treatment. Prior to purchase, verification allows the buyer to know there is no financial conflict of interest if the certificate is from an independent laboratory. The certificate also assists you when purchasing an insurance policy for your purchase, if desired.
Financing Options
Brilliant Earth offers financing options through two companies; The first is Affirm, offering payment plans of up to 36 months. The other is Wells Fargo, which offers special financing for 12 months with approved credit. Both are available to U.S customers only.
Ritani uses Affirm as well. They also utilize the Klarna app. As long as your purchase is under $2000, you can choose 4 interest-free payments. The other option is to contact them so they can advise you.
Guarantees
Brilliant Earth offers free 30-day returns and lifetime manufacturing warranty on all jewelry. Some jewelry items are non-returnable, such as custom designed jewelry, personalized fine jewelry, and rings that have been resized or modified, among others. They must be returned in their original box and be unworn.
Ritani also offers free 30-day returns on all engagement rings and wedding bands; items ineligible for return include personalized jewelry, final sale products, and any special orders.
Why Choose Brilliant Earth?

- Image and video quality: The videos of the diamonds are very sharp, and the photos of the jewelry are also high-quality.
- Gemstones: There is an impressive selection of gems and shapes to choose from. Certain gemstones are hard to find online, so a wide variety sets them apart from other sellers.
- More diamond shapes: Including trending shapes including elongated cushion cut and old mine cut. Brilliant Earth has thousands of choices to fit your budget and preference.
- Chance to design a ring of your own creation: You can design your own ring from scratch with design experts.
- Jane Goodall Collection: 10% of net proceeds from sales from the Jane Goodall Collection are donated to the Jane Goodall Legacy Foundation Fund to help support conservation, research, and education programs.
- Their modern designs: It features contemporary and modern ring designs with organic lines that follow bridal trends.
- Everyday transparent pricing: You don’t have to wait for a sale to get a competitive price. Brilliant Earth offers frequent promotions or gifts with purchase on eligible orders.
Why Choose Ritani?

- Discounts: Ritani frequently offers deals and discount coupons on all its products, including diamonds.
- Price transparency: The sales costs appear below each diamond, showing you the Ritani markup.
- Loyalty program: Ritani Rewards members earn points for purchases and exclusive rewards every time they shop.
- Market comparison: If the diamond you chose is also sold by other online sellers, Ritani compares it and shows you the price to compare, and it matches identical diamonds if you find a lower price elsewhere.
Final Thoughts

Brilliant Earth targets an environmentally conscious audience that also appreciates current trends. Its website is well-organized and clearly focuses on fine jewelry, as its key products include engagement rings, wedding sets for men and women, as well as earrings, bracelets, rings, charms, and necklaces. If you are looking for diamond or gemstone pieces and want a wide range of designs and stones, you have come to the right place. Their everyday competitive pricing, along with a free gift with purchase provides definite advantages to purchasing from them.
Ritani focuses on price and overall inventory. This is confirmed when browsing their website, as the first things you see are offers or discount coupons. It targets an audience more interested in finding low prices along with having a large inventory at their fingertips than in design, aesthetics, and exclusivity. Ritani also has more than just engagement and wedding rings, with necklaces, charms, bracelets, and earrings as well.
Now that you have a comparison of these brands, all that’s left is to choose which of the two suits you best.
