Skip to Content

Moissanite Vintage Engagement Ring Ideas (Vintage-Inspired)

Moissanite Vintage Engagement Ring Ideas (Vintage-Inspired)

The first vintage ring I ever owned was a simple spoon ring. It was never valuable, but it was meaningful to me, with beautiful Art Deco engraving. You don’t have to spend a fortune on an engagement ring for brilliance and sparkle. That’s why I’m so passionate about sharing my ideas for the best vintage-inspired moissanite engagement rings.  Whether you long for a floral vintage engagement ring or one with striking geometric designs, I can’t wait to share my favorite designs with you. By showing you how to select the very best moissanite engagement rings, I’ll make sure your purchase is worth it. No matter what ring you buy, it’ll be both meaningful and crafted with exquisite vintage details.

Best Online Moissanite Retailer
The BEST Place to Buy Moissanite?

Without a doubt, my go-to moissanite Jeweler is Forever Moissanite. They are have the best selection of moissanite diamonds AND a digital first customer orientation. SAVE 10% with code SAVE10 right here.

View Moissanite Selection
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.
Keep in mind that Moissanite rings are technically not vintage. This is why all of my picks say vintage-inspired. To be truly vintage, a ring needs to be over 4 decades old. Moissanite was first widely offered in the 1990s within the jewelry industry, so everything would be “vintage-inspired.” Bottom Line Up Front Summary:  If I had to select just one vintage-inspired moissanite engagement ring, it would be this Marquise Forever One Moissanite Soliatire Ring crafted by Charles & Colvard. This ring is the most simple, but also most versatile on my list. It’s ideal for someone who loves vintage designs but also modern simplicity. It’s offered at a great price and it’s easy to complement with other rings. 

My Top Picks

  1. Forever Moissanite Split Shank Vintage Cushion Cut: Best Overall 
  2. Marquise Forever One Moissanite Solitaire : Best Minimalist Engagement Ring
  3. Moissanite Entwined Celtic Love Knot Ring: Best Meaningful Engagement Ring 
  4. Moissanite Arabesque Lab Diamond Ring: Best Ring with Diamond Accents 
  5. Emerald Forever One Moissanite Solitaire: Best Ring over 3 Carats 
  6. Moissanite Lily Lab Diamond Ring: Best Nature-Inspired Engagement Ring 
  7. Moissanite Canela Ring: Best Princess Cut Engagement Ring 
  8. Moissanite Black Rhodium Cadenza Halo Ring: Best Art Deco Engagement Ring
  9. Cushion Forever One Moissanite Halo Ring: Best Halo Engagement Ring 
  10. Moissanite Reina Ring with Accents: Best Royalty-Inspired Engagement Ring
  11. Forever Moissanite Vintage Floral Design Cushion Cut: Best Floral Design

Vintage vs Vintage-Inspired Engagement Rings

I want to be upfront about vintage vs vintage-inspired engagement rings because this is important if you’re considering the value of your moissanite engagement ring. A vintage ring is something that is truly from another era. I’ve seen some rings labeled as a vintage that are either newly crafted or come from the decade I was born, which was the 90s. For a ring to be truly vintage, it must be at least 40 years old. Vintage-inspired rings are rings that mimic the designs of an era but were crafted long after. While unique and beautiful, they don’t carry the same resale value.  Moissanite engagement rings have only been around since the mid to late 1990s. Because of this, you can only buy vintage-inspired rings, not truly vintage rings if moissanite is your stone of choice. 

Vintage-Inspired Styles 

With that out of the way, I have good news: there are countless beautiful vintage designs and settings you can consider for a moissanite engagement ring. The most popular eras and styles and noted below. In general, vintage-inspired rings have more details on the band and play with angles and curves more than a modern ring. While modern moissanite engagement rings favor sleek and minimalist designs, vintage-inspired rings add gorgeous details that complement the center stone. 

Popular Eras 

  • The 1920s
  • The 1930s
  • The 1940s
  • The 1950s
  • 1980s (not truly vintage)

Popular Designs and Styles

  • Art Deco (Geometric Shapes)
  • Flower and Nature-Inspired
  • Twisted Bands 
  • Celtic Knot
  • Hidden Halo
  • Unique Cuts and Settings
    • Marquise, Old European, Emerald, Princess, Pear, Baguette, Tear Drop 

Tips for Buying a Moissanite Engagement Ring

First things first: it’s important to understand the main differences between a moissanite vs a diamond engagement ring (read my article to learn all of the differences). But in short, a moissanite engagement ring is not as valuable as a diamond ring. Moissanite is only slightly softer, rated at a 9.25 vs 10 on the Mohs hardness scale. White moissanite doesn’t look like a diamond when exposed to light due to its rainbow scintillation. That said, a moissanite engagement ring is a good choice for its unique beauty and value, as long as you know how to select the best quality. 

Tip #1: Value Color and Clarity Over Carat

Color and clarity are most important if you want a sparkling center stone. I recommend moissanite that’s either colorless or nearly colorless to avoid yellow and warm undertones. Moissanite needs to have at least eye clean or very slightly included (VS, preferably VVS) clarity.

Tip #2: Consider Cut

I love subtle sparkle, especially for a vintage-inspired moissanite ring. Round and cushion cuts are the most brilliant, but high-quality oval and princess cuts are also great. The deeper the cut, the more subtle the brilliance. Some cuts and shapes, of course, are associated with different eras. 

Tip #3: Make Sure It’s Not Fake

I’ve seen deceptive listings. You might search for moissanite and come across some red flag descriptions, including:

  • Diamond Simulant
  • Man-Made
  • Manufactured 

All of these point to a stimulant, like cubic zirconia, rather than genuine lab-grown or natural moissanite. I would never purchase a moissanite engagement ring from a seller with no reviews, from a website that doesn’t have a secure connection or a listing without any details about the quality grading. 

Tip #4: Buy a Metal Band the Lasts

A sterling silver moissanite ring is a beautiful and affordable option. But if you’re buying an engagement ring, I highly recommend a metal don’t won’t easily tarnish. My favorite options are 14Kor 18K gold, as well as platinum, all of which offer a beautiful luster and are durable. I’d never buy regular gold-plated rings or base metals (such as copper) for a ring I want to wear every day. 

Who Has Vintage-Inspired Moissanite Engagement Rings?

Something exciting for me is trying to find unique rings– and it’s a challenge to find vintage-inspired moissanite engagement rings. JCPenney, Kohl’s, Charles & Colvard, Helzberg, Amazon, and Etsy are a few places you can buy moissanite engagement rings in stores or online. But for the finest quality, vintage-inspired rings, only three places stood out to me as the very best.

Company/ Jeweler Pros Cons
Brilliant Earth
  • Environmentally Conscious 
  • Ethical Sourcing
  • Beautiful Quality
  • Custom/ Create Your Own 
  • A+  BBB Rating
  • Free Lifetime Warranty 
  • Most Expensive
  • Fewer Options for Vintage-Inspired vs Modern 
Charles & Colvard
  • Forever One Moissanite (See My Review Here)
  • Gorgeous Craftsmanship
  • A+ BBB Rating 
  • Warranty Available 
  • No Create-Your-Own 
  • Still Expensive (But Cheaper, Usually, then Brilliant Earth)
  • Very Limited Options for Platinum Rings
Etsy 
  • Handcrafted Rings
  • Unique Designs
  • Supports Smaller Jewelers/ Artisans 
  • Wide Variety (Prices & Styles) 
  • Quality Varies
  • Must be Extra Careful When Shopping
  • Shipping Delays
  • Must Check for Warranty/ Return Policies (Vary by Listing) 

My Ideas: Vintage-Inspired Moissanite Engagement Rings

The last thing I want is for you to buy a moissanite engagement ring and for it to become a regret. With that in mind. I’ve appraised a range of vintage-inspired moissanite rings, across designers, and found the highest-quality and most unique rings. These vintage-inspired moissanite rings are gorgeous and most include financing options if you can’t pay out of pocket. Finally, all of these rings offer moissanite and metal bands that are meant to last a lifetime. 

Forever Moissanite Split Shank Vintage Cushion Cut Moissanite Ring

There are 24 stunning small stones that all accentuate the beautiful stone located in the middle of this ring. I love how this ring definitely has vintage vibes, but doesn’t look outdated. The split shank part of this ring helps to keep this piece of jewelry updated! I know that if I were to buy a bigger stone, I would want more than four prongs to hold onto my ring. But, that’s just my personal preference! Buy Here.

Split Shank Vintage Cushion Cut Moissanite Engagement Ring | Forever Moissanite

This Stunning Moissanite Split Shank Vintage Cushion Cut Engagement Ring is available in White, Yellow or Rose Solid Gold (14K or 18K) and also in Platinum.

Check Price
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.

Pros

  • You can choose from 1.00 carat all the way up to 3.00 carats
  • Customizable ring; you can choose to get the ring in white gold, yellow gold, rose gold, or platinum
  • Added carat weight of 0.12 carats thanks to 24 added side stones

Cons 

  • Only four prongs are available, which I don’t think is very secure for a bigger stone 

Marquise Forever One Moissanite Solitaire Engagement Ring in 14K Gold

This gorgeous vintage-inspired ring is effortlessly elegant. The sleek craftsmanship blends modern and vintage styles for a beautiful sense of timelessness. The marquise-cut moissanite stone is secured with a six-prong setting. The dazzling, colorless stone is complemented by a knife-edge band. The craftsmanship here is refined and alluring in an understated way. I adore this ring for anyone torn between vintage and modern styles. Buy in Yellow Gold Here or Buy in White Gold Here

Pros

  • Knife Edge Shank
  • Gorgeous Marquise Stone
  • Elegant and Timeless

Cons

  • Modest Carat (0.50)
  • Fairly Simple 

Moissanite Entwined Celtic Love Knot Ring

I admit a fondness for Celtic knots. Maybe it’s my Irish or Scottish heritage, or maybe it’s just the beautiful symbolism. A Celtic knot symbolizes eternal bond and eternal love. I also see it as a symbol of perseverance and strength. This vintage-inspired ring exudes brilliance with a prong-set, round brilliant-cut center stone. The twisted shank is simply stunning for a meaningful ring unlike most on the market. It’s available in 18K white, yellow, or rose gold as well as platinum. Buy Here

Pros

  • Meaningful Symbol
  • Gorgeous Twisted Shank 
  • Brilliant Round Cut 

Cons

  • No Accent Stones
  • Culturally Specific 

Moissanite Arabesque Moissanite & Lab Diamond Ring

If you can’t decide between a lab diamond and moissanite, you’re not alone. And with this dazzling, ornate engagement ring, you don’t have to. This engagement ring is fit for royalty, with an alternating baguette and round diamonds. The central round moissanite stone radiates brilliance and fire. This statement ring is simply gorgeous, with ½ carat total weight of sparkling gemstones. Choose from 18K gold (rose, yellow, white) or platinum. Buy Here

Pros

  • Accent Lab-Grown Diamonds
  • Rhodium Finish for Improved Durability
  • Excellent Moissanite Clarity 

Cons

  • Slight Inclusions on Diamonds
  • Modest Carat 

Emerald Forever One Moissanite Solitaire with Accents Engagement Ring

Large carat-rings and small budgets don’t go together. But what if I told you there’s an exceptional vintage-inspired moissanite ring over 3.5 carats and well under $5,000. This ring is crafted with attention to detail, with sparkling round accent stones. The unique emerald center stone is secured with unique double prongs. The 14K gold shank is sleek and subtle– the perfect accent to make the moissanite shine. Buy Yellow Here or Buy White Here

Pros

  • Generous Carat Weight for Price
  • Beautiful Double Prongs
  • Excellent Color and Clarity 

Cons

  • Emerald-Cut is Less Brilliant 
  • Not as Detailed Craftsmanship 

Moissanite Lily Ring with Accent Diamonds

One of my favorite ideas for a vintage-inspired moissanite engagement ring? Embracing nature is a sure way to find a gorgeous ring. Not only that, but nature-inspired rings almost always bring unique symbolism. A lily is a symbol of love, beauty, and change. This ornate lily ring features a moissanite center stone. Accent lab-grown diamonds sparkle along with the petite twisted vine band. Crafted in your choice of 14K gold (yellow, white, or rose) or platinum, this is one of the most glamorous and unique rings I highly recommend. Buy Here

Pros

  • 3D Lily Motif
  • Diamond Accents on Twisted Shank
  • Exceptional Colorless Round Moissanite 

Cons

  • Modest Carat Weight
  • Not Available in 18K Gold 

Moissanite Canela Ring

I always say that princess cut engagement rings are underrated, and my statement stands. This gorgeous princess cut ring features colorless moissanite. The brilliance of this moissanite stone isn’t the only highlight, however. The center stone is situated on a unique, engraved band. The detailed craftsmanship evokes tree branches and natural elements. The luster of the metal elevates this style. I simply love the unique band paired with the princess cut. It’s sleek but still vintage-inspired and can be stacked with other bands. This ring is available in your choice of 18K gold or platinum. Buy Here

Pros

  • Engraved Band 
  • Gorgeous Princess Cut Center Stone
  • Beautiful Clarity 

Cons

  • Limited Sizes 
  • Slightly Expensive for Carat Weight

Moissanite Black Rhodium Cadenza Halo Lab Diamond Ring

I know that this moissanite engagement ring isn’t for everyone, but it’s easily one of my favorites if you’re looking for a truly unique design. The shank is crafted with a milgrain design, accent with lab-grown diamonds. The exquisite attention to detail is in of itself remarkable, but it’s the black rhodium paired with the marquise diamonds that sells it for me. This show-stopping ring is crafted in 18K white gold. Icy hues with black details evoke both Victorian and Edwardian aesthetics. Buy Here

Pros

  • Miligrain Details
  • Black Accents 
  • Victorian/ Edwardian 

Cons

  • Modest Carat Weight (⅕)
  • Hard to Match 

Cushion Forever One Moissanite Framed Halo Engagement Ring

Halo rings are usually expensive, but this vintage-inspired ring is a great value. What distinguishes this moissanite engagement ring from a more modem one is the unique framework around the center stone. The ornate edging is refined, with accent pear-shaped moissanite stones. The slight curve to the 14K gold band and sheer romantic beauty of this ring make it a stunning option at a fair price. Even better, with colorless forever one moissanite along with the entire band, you’re sure to notice unique brilliance and sophisticated sparkle. Buy Here

Pros

  • Over 2 Carats Total
  • Ornate Framing 
  • Beautiful Brilliance and Fire

Cons

  • No 18K Gold or Platinum 
  • Not Quite as Unique 

Moissanite Reina Engagement Ring

This is my personal favorite vintage-inspired moissanite engagement ring, and I hope that you can see why. This regal engagement ring takes inspiration from royalty, with ornate but refined details that are crafted with precision. A curved halo with pear-shaped cutouts provides a shimmering accent to the center moissanite stone. My favorite version of this ring is with a classic cushion cut for the center stone, along with a rose gold band. But no matter how it is ordered, The scalloped pavé diamonds perfectly accent the gorgeous moissanite stone. This is a ring that’s hard to take your eyes away from. Buy Here

Pros

  • Glittering Scalloped Pavé Diamonds 
  • Ornate Halo
  • Beautiful Craftsmanship 

Cons

  • Slight Inclusions on Diamonds
  • Less Versatile 

Final Buying Recommendation: Moissanite Vintage-Inspired Engagement Rings from Etsy

While I love so many of the vintage-inspired moissanite engagement rings sold by Brilliant Earth and Charles and Colvard, sometimes you want something truly unique. Etsy has a selection of handcrafted moissanite engagement rings. These made-to-order rings cover some of the most popular vintage designs, from Art Deco to nature-inspired. What I love about this option is that you’re supporting small jewelers and artists. The key is to shop smart. Make sure that the ring band is crafted with genuine gold or platinum, not gold plating. Check the description to make sure that it’s genuine moissanite, with grading for color and clarity. Sometimes listings for cubic zirconia rings get mixed in with moissanite rings. Shop Vintage-Inspired Moissanite Rings on Etsy Here.

ChicVidaFineJewelry Vintage Moissanite Engagement Ring

This Art Deco ring is handcrafted with beautiful details. The made-to-order engagement ring ‘wows’ with a colorless pear-shaped stone. This halo-style ring showcases the most glamorous side of vintage-inspired moissanite rings, and I especially love it in 18K yellow gold. The dazzling array of accent stones and the curved band provide a breathtaking dramatic look. It’s available in 14K to 18K rose, white and yellow gold. Buy Here.

Pros

Cons

  • Slower Shipping
  • Limited Stock

Tyler Fine Jewelry Forever One antique-inspired Engagement Ring

Priced at under $1,000, this unique vintage-inspired ring is one I had to mention. The stunning style has an antique allure, complemented with a genuine Forever One center stone. The sleek band is adjustable and crafted in your choice of 14K or 18K white, rose, or yellow gold. What sets it apart is how the halo of accent stones is layered to add sparkling dimension. I love that this ring displays a balance of glamour and elegant simplicity. All told, this ring proves you don’t have to spend a fortune on a vintage-inspired moissanite engagement ring.  Buy Here.

Pros

  • Budget-Friendly
  • Antique Details
  • Genuine Forever One Stone

Cons

  • Modest Carat Weight
  • More Challenging to Stack

FYM Jewelry Design Cluster Vintage Moissanite Engagement Ring Set

I mentioned before that floral, vine, leaf and other nature motifs all are some of the most beautiful vintage-inspired designs. This holds with this exquisite engagement ring set. The engagement ring radiates fire and brilliance with an oval-cut center stone. Five accent petals on the other side flank the stone with whimsical sparkle. Meanwhile, the marching band would be perfect for a boho-style wedding. This ring set is available in 14K or 18K white, rose, or yellow gold. To me, it proves again that diamond alternative engagement rings can be just as gorgeous. Buy Here.

Pros

  • Nature Motifs
  • Truly Unique Vintage-Inspired Style
  • Your Choice of 14K or 18K Gold

Cons

  • Modest Carat
  • Less Sourcing Information (if you opt for diamonds)

Forever Moissanite Vintage Floral Cushion Cut

Sure, there are a lot of beautiful rings on this list. But, I think this is one of the most beautiful ones! I love how the center stone looks like a budding rose. The side stones are beautifully placed too. There are 60 side stones on this ring, which add 0.42 carats to this ring. Talk about breathtaking, am I right? Plus, I love how you can customize the rings you get from Forever Moissanite, so that’s always a plus for me. Buy Here.

Vintage Floral Design Cushion Cut Moissanite Engagement Ring | Forever Moissanite

The ring can be customized to your exact specifications to accommodate a center stone from 1.00 to 3.00 carats and it comes as pictured with an additional 60 round brilliant cut side stones, in total carat weight of 0.42 Ct.

Check Price
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.

Pros

  • Over 60 side stones, which help to add unique detail to this ring
  • This beautiful moissanite ring looks like a budding rose, without the thorns
  • Hand cut stone

Cons

  • You can only go up to 3.00 carats 

Frequently Asked Questions

Question: Where can I buy a vintage-inspired moissanite engagement ring for under $500?

Answer: You can find engagement rings with a vintage design under $500 if you shop wisely. Sterling silver and 10K gold rings drop the price. The carat size must be quite modest, too. I would always opt for a lower carat while retaining quality standards for metal type and an eye-clean stone. The best place to shop for cheap rings is Etsy. This Vintage Style Moissanite Ring features an antique milgrain band and is well under $500.

Question: What does a moissanite engagement ring symbolize?

Answer: The meaning and lore of moissanite aren’t as well-known as a diamond, but it’s still a beautiful message. Moissanite is a strong stone, pointing to a strong connection between two people. I also love that it’s been tied to ambition and future potential.

Question: Does Zales, Tiffany’s, James Allen, or Jared sell moissanite engagement rings?

Answer: Many traditional jewelers don’t sell moissanite rings. If you want in-person and online shopping from a jewelry chain, your best option is Kay Jewelers. Surprisingly, Kohl’s also sells a collection of moissanite engagement rings. Always call your local store first to check for availability.

Final Thoughts

There’s nothing quite like a vintage-inspired ring. No matter what style you decide on, it’s sure to be a unique, expressive ring with a sense of timelessness. While moissanite is relatively new to the scene for truly vintage rings, a vintage-inspired ring will provide the same iconic designs at a reasonable price. Moissanite engagement rings continue to rise in popularity, and while they are not the same as diamond engagement rings, they have a unique brilliance and beauty of their own. If you need even more style ideas, I love looking on Pinterest. It’s a great way to create an inspiration board so you have an idea of what you’re looking for even before you start shopping.

Best Online Moissanite Retailer
The BEST Place to Buy Moissanite?

Without a doubt, my go-to moissanite Jeweler is Forever Moissanite. They are have the best selection of moissanite diamonds AND a digital first customer orientation. SAVE 10% with code SAVE10 right here.

View Moissanite Selection
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.

Looking for more inspirational readings? Check out: