Best Wedding Gifts for Your Sister: AMAZING and Original

Imagine just having a beautiful ceremony and heading off to a honeymoon to New Zealand. Then imagine, hundreds of thousands of miles in the air during a connecting flight, you get another surprise: cards and notes from 130 passengers wishing you well.

Fantastical as it sounds, that’s precisely what happened for Bride Kelli Shultz this April when as the receiving end of one of the best wedding gift ideas from her sister.

Handing out goodie bags to all 130 passengers, she slipped in a note, explaining her sister had just gotten married and she wanted a final send-off. That’s not to say that all the best wedding gift ideas for a sister have to be so grand. But it does go to show that personalization and a lot of thought go further than a high price tag.

In a Hurry? Top Options Sure to Impress (and not totally lame)

  1. Delicious Indie Snack Box Subscription (pickles, sweets, cheese, etc…) – $50 – 60 on
  2. Customized Cutting Board (with their name) – $25 – 50 on
  3. Epic Wine Subscription (with their favorites) – $30 – 100 on CaliforniaWineClub
  4. Concierge Name Change Service (remove the headache of last name changes) – $30 – 50 on
  5. [amazon_textlink asin=’B013WFOBYA’ text=’Samsonite Luggage Set‘ template=’ProductLink’ store=’loveyoutomorrow-20′ marketplace=’US’ link_id=’95481bef-2695-4b50-a2e8-84ba7da1ccf8′] (wanderlust) – $150 – 300 on Amazon



The pressure for a “perfect” gift

There’s plenty of pressure when it comes to gifts in general for weddings. For the engaged couple, there’s all the planning and energy that goes into picking a wedding registry. Guests might worry how much or how little to spend. And family members likely feel pressured to buy a gift that goes above and beyond the registry.

The truth? There’s no such thing as a perfect gift. But there are some things family members, especially those close to the bride, like sisters, do that are big mistakes, namely:

  • Focusing too much on how much or how little they’re spending
  • Write off ‘practical gifts.’
  • Forget personal touches
  • Make a purchase based on others’ (real or perceived) expectations)

Make no mistake: the best wedding gift ideas for your sister are the ones that reflect who she is, aside from being a bride. Whether expensive or more affordable, the best gift ideas are ones that will stand the test of time.

Gift-giving as a sister, or Maid of Honor?

 maid of honor gifts

It may not seem significant, but your role in a wedding makes a difference in what gift you’re giving. But here, the distinction is less clear: many sisters are also the Maid of Honor. In that case, however, being a sister still trumps being a Maid of Honor.

And sisters who aren’t a Maid of Honor need not worry–their gift is still just as important. In both cases, traditional wedding gifts are excellent, but more personalized gifts help show how much your sister means to you.

A few more things to keep in mind

The best wedding gift ideas will:

  • still be in your budget
  • express your relationship (the good parts)
  • be your idea

It’s okay to bounce ideas off of others, but ultimately you know your sister best. While this article will give you a starting point for some great ideas (and a few places to purchase gifts), ultimately you need to make sure your purchase is made with you and your sister in mind.

The Best Wedding Gift Ideas

wedding quilt

  1. Wedding Quilts or Throws: This idea actually is a very old tradition that over the decades has lost popularity, in part because not nearly as many people know how to, or have the time, to sew anymore. But even if you’re a complete novice to all things sewing related, you can still have something custom-made.

The story behind wedding quilts is the story behind many traditional wedding gifts. Primarily in Europe during the 18th and 19th centuries, family members sent young women with quilts as a form of an endowment before they got married.

Thankfully, the endowments have mostly vanished in the United States and Europe, but there is a part of the tradition that can still be touching and yet modern. Aside from its connection to a dowry, handmade quilts were often stitched with personal details and used as a way to commemorate life-changing events.

Today, you can create a personalized throw or rug that no one shows what the bride means to you, but also preserves the memory of her wedding (and keeps her warm!) Here are some of our favorite ideas:

  • Etsy, Custom Wedding Photo Memory Quilt; $260.00: A 50’ by 65’ custom designed quilt allows you to select a custom color and photos for a trip down memory lane.
  • Personalization Mall, Personalized Fleece Blanket; $69.99 (on sale for $48.99): Select from 4 color options, two sizes, and add 10 lines or personalized phrases to describe either the bride’s or the couples’ favorite things.

#1 Unique Pendant Necklaces

Fine jewelry might be appreciated by many, but selecting something with a personal flair shows how much you care. Not only are pendant necklaces still very much in style, but there’s also a sense of timelessness to a piece of jewelry with personal meaning.

pendant necklace

The best part? There are so many options when it comes to what you can find, or even customize. Sterling silver, yellow gold, gemstones, and tiny diamonds add that special touch worthy of a wedding.

  • Brilliant Earth, Birthstone Twist Pendant, $275.00: If you’re a little shy of getting something over-the-top personal for your sister, this gift idea is an excellent place to start. The stunning necklace is made of recycled silver (great for eco-minded brides) and features a gemstone with a bezel setting.
  • The Blue Nile, Monica Rich Kosann Petite Oval Locket, $1,395.00: Not as fond of pendants? Lockets have a vintage feel, but they also are more personal. This stunning locket from the Blue Nile is made with 18K Rose Gold and decorative chevron details on the exterior.

#2 An Experience or Fund

This is a less conventional gift idea for your sister, but it’s still one of the best. In fact, many couples are an option to add non-material things to their wedding registries. The most popular? Requesting funds for a honeymoon. Something like kick starting a Honeyfund is both intentional and flexible for the couple.

If you feel like you want something that feels a little more special, no worries: you can come up with your idea. Just be sure that it’s something that your sister would enjoy, and if you’re not sure, it’s better to go with low-pressure things, like a trip to the spa, or a weekend getaway. Here are some more ideas, courtesy of Zola:

While in some ways it’s the riskiest of ideas for a gift, it can also be rewarding if you know it’s something your sister has always dreamed of doing and experience she won’t forget.

#3 Personalized Decor

personalized decor

No doubt this idea won’t be popular with everyone, but personalized decor for the home is both practical and meaningful and a great wedding gift for your sister.

The trick is standing out from other guests, who might have a similar idea. So instead of opting for perfunctory monogrammed towels (which some couples aren’t fond of anyway) give a gift as only a close family member could provide.

That means gifts that reflect who you are as sisters, or what family means to both of you:

  • Things Remembered, Jeweled Family Tree, $60.000: So this might be a better gift idea for parents of the bride, but hear us out: given as a gift along with other family members, this gift could be significant, and a beautiful way to display where your family started (and for potential future family members). That said, this is only for a particular type of bride. If your sister is into genealogy, this is a unique pick.
  • Things Remembered, Willow Tree ‘Together’ Figurine, $45.00: Willow Tree makes a beautiful line of figurines that are simple but emotive. While this particular one is a great idea to honor the couple, you could also consider looking into one dedicated specifically for sisters. Add a personalized note and bottom inscription.

#5 Charm Bracelets


No, charm bracelets aren’t only for kids. Charm bracelets purchased from fine jewelry are beautiful, whimsical, and wonderful keepsakes. By option for a charm bracelet, you’ll be giving your sister a wedding gift that shares memories, showcases her best traits, and will be unique to your relationship with her.

Plus, charm bracelets are a time-honored gift, once meant for good luck and keeping away bad fortune. No matter if your sister believes in superstition or not, it’s a fun, lighthearted nod while still staying elegant:

  • Kay Jewelers, Create-Your-Own, prices vary: Individual charms range from as low as $4.99 to over $1,500. With such a large selection, you’ll find charms of every style, price point, and theme, from religious to fun. Sterling silver, yellow gold, rose gold, white gold, and silver and gold tone options. Sort by theme, price point, reviews, stone, and featured collections to build a one-of-a-kind bracelet for your sister.

#6 A Video or Photo Album

This is such a classic gift that many sisters might shy away from it, worried it is not unique enough to celebrate a wedding. But it’s also becoming an increasingly rare gift and one that will be revisited time after time.

If you’re are going this route, you might consider both a physical and digital version. And you’ll want to assemble more than just photos or clips: stitch together a timeline that shares your fondest memories growing up and sneak in some she might not have gotten in all the events and preparations leading up to her wedding.

#7 A Keepsake Box

A keepsake box is not only unexpected, but it’s also practical, elegant, and a great idea to give a sister.

keepsake box

While a bride can use a keepsake box for anything she likes, it’s especially great for keeping souvenirs from her wedding, like stationary, dried corsages, and a leftover gift favor (as long as it’s non-perishable!).

  • Savor, Wedding Edition Keepsake Box, $99.95: Select from indigo or slate. Acid-free drawers illustrated frames, and beautifully stitched frames. Each box is both handcrafted and ‘custom-dyed’ and can even hold objects like cake toppers and ring pillows.
  • The Bradford Exchange, Personalized Bridal Music Box, $59.99: If you don’t see your sister saving a lot of little knick-knacks from her wedding, a music box is a similar idea but an equally beautiful choice. This one includes a silver-plated lid and customized etching.

Recommended Reads:

Sue Fox

Love You Tomorrow was founded by Sue Fox, a jewelry and wedding enthusiast from New York. Her father, Simon, was a jewelry appraiser, whose family had deep roots in the mining industry. Sue grew up schooled in the different properties of gems and metals, as well as in the care and appraisal of jewelry. She was most fascinated by how different gems, materials, cuts, and settings could be put together in endless combinations to make thousands of unique pieces of jewelry. Best of all, each piece was distinct in its purpose and design to match the personality of the wearer. Love You Tomorrow began as a passion project in 2016. This was around the time when many of Sue’s friends and family members were getting married. Knowing her expertise, they often sought out her advice on wedding and engagement rings. The blog started out as a place to house Sue’s now in-demand knowledge. Her first posts were buying guides for diamonds, roundups of her favorite ring recommendations around the web, and practical tips about choosing the right gemstone for you. It became apparent pretty quickly that the most common visitors to her blog were couples in the market for wedding and engagement rings. Since rings were only one item on an engaged couple’s to-do list, Sue also began to receive inquiries about how the perfect rings would fit into the rest of the whole wedding picture. Since then, Sue’s vision for the blog expanded to become a one-stop shop for other resources on weddings in general. Today, Love You Tomorrow is a wedding blog that features not just Sue’s expertise on wedding and engagement rings, but also insights from her “Wedding Party”, a team of wedding experts and enthusiasts who write guides, recommendations, and tips for happy couples looking to tie the knot. Sue is now currently based in Carmel-by-the-Sea on the Monterey Peninsula in California. She lives with her husband Jess, and their three dogs, Sleepy, Dopey, and Doc.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below