Blue Nile vs Tiffany Compared [2020]: Which Retailer is Better?

Last Updated on

Blue Nile and Tiffany & Co. are both upscale, preeminent, jewelry retailers known for their diamond engagement rings.

However, there are some significant differences between the two, and being informed of them is important when making a momentous decision like purchasing an engagement ring.

Read on to discover the advantages and disadvantages of purchasing from both companies.

My Top Line Up Front: While I prefer Blue Nile for having a better ONLINE customer experience, I ALSO like a completely different retailer overall. MY new favorite online retailer has to be James Allen here, with superior visual graphics (360 high-def), better prices, and consistently higher customer service.

First Up: Tiffany & Co.

Headquartered in New York City, Tiffany & Co. is a trusted, time-honored staple of diamond jewelry. Tiffany & Co. was founded in 1837, and today currently has 284 stores in 22 countries including the United States. A Tiffany and Co. gemologist was partly responsible for the global ratification of the carat system as a weight regulation for gemstones.

In addition to jewelry, Tiffany & Co. offers:

  • Watches
  • Fragrances
  • Furniture
  • Décor
  • Eyewear
  • Handbags

Tiffany & Co. has extremely strict standards for their diamonds – they only accept 0.04% of the world’s gem-grade diamonds and only near colorless and higher. Their philosophy is this: bigger is not better; clarity and color are emphasized over carat, and cut is the most important factor.

In elegant display, Tiffany & Co.’s website details the stories of their diamonds and the rigorous five-step, year-long process they endure to become a Tiffany diamond:

  • Mining: Tiffany & Co. procures their diamonds crude and through direct sourcing. Tiffany & Co. has helped set the stage for responsible mining, and refuses to do so in places of ecological importance such as Yellowstone National Park.
  • Cutting: At Tiffany & Co., cutting a diamond is said to be an art-form. Tiffany diamonds are cut in Tiffany & Co.’s own studio, where highly experienced Tiffany cutters follow a precise process.
  • Polishing: Tiffany diamonds are polished in a state-of-the-art workshop, where jobs and training programs take place. 94% of polishers in Tiffany’s & Co.’s Botswana studios are locally hired.
  • Grading Each Tiffany diamond is graded in Tiffany’s & Co.’s Gemological laboratory in New York. If the measurements are off by so much as a fraction of a millimeter, it will be returned to cutting and polishing. In addition, if a stone has too much fluorescence, it will not be accepted by Tiffany.
  • Setting- Since every Tiffany diamond is original, each one of their settings is custom- built to exalt the diamond. Tiffany settings come in platinum, 18k yellow gold and rose gold. Before being placed in Tiffany’s signature blue box, every surface is gone over with a buffer.

In addition to engagement rings, Tiffany & Co. has thousands of pieces of jewelry as part of several collections, including their 14 Tiffany collections, which in turn include:

  • Tiffany Keys: a beautiful, charming, original collection of key pendants and bracelets.
  • Tiffany T: a collection of rings, bracelets, earrings and necklaces that feature Tiffany’s signature “T” design.
  • Tiffany Hardwear: a collection of industrial-style jewelry and Tiffany & Co.’s unique “ball” jewelry.
  • Return to Tiffany: necklaces, bracelets, charms and pendants all featuring the “Return to Tiffany, New York 925” inscription.
  • Tiffany Soleste: a vibrant collection of gemstones and colored diamonds encircled with white diamonds.
  • Tiffany Yellow Diamonds: a stunning collection of rare yellow diamond jewelry.

Tiffany and Co. also has the one of a kind Tiffany high jewelry, which comprises some of the most dazzling, indulgent, unrivaled pieces around.

Tiffany and Co. also three designer jewelry collections: Elsa Peretti, Paloma Picasso, and Tiffany & Co. Schlumberger

Next Up: Blue Nile

Headquartered in Seattle, Washington, Blue Nile has been the largest online diamond retailer since 1999. Through Blue Nile’s website, you can design and build your own diamond engagement ring or take advantage of their pre-made Blue Nile offers.

It also features an entire section of information on diamonds, including the 4 C’s, as well as the rules Blue Nile abides by, including not only the Kimberly Process, but “The Golden Rules”, a policy of draft gold and precious metals sourcing. Blue Nile adheres to high ethical standards when it comes to their diamonds, thus they do not buy diamonds from Zimbabwe, and they have a zero-tolerance policy in place regarding conflict diamonds.

Blue Nile has literally thousands of loose white and color diamonds available on their website, and you can search, browse and compare diamonds based on price and shape as well as the 4 C’s. Blue Nile also has extensive information on each diamond, in addition to the 4 C’s, under their Summary tab, including:

  • Symmetry
  • Polish
  • Girdle
  • Cutlet
  • Depth
  • Fluorescence
  • Table
  • Measurements

The Blue Nile website features its signature Astor by Blue Nile diamond collection. This collection is graded by GIA and GemEx, which is the leader in light measurement. Every Astor by Blue Nile diamond is cut to reflect the most light, which in turn is measured by fire, brilliance and sparkle. Astor by Blue Nile diamonds are rare and feature superior cuts, proportions, and symmetry.

Blue Nile features designer engagement ring collections including: Colin Cowie, Monique Lhuillier, Zac Posen and Bella Vaughan

Blue Nile also has several unique, signature, engagement-ring setting collections including Sapphire Sidestones and Vintage.

In addition to diamonds and engagement rings, Blue Nile also over a thousand diamond and gemstone bracelets, earrings, pendants and necklaces, including jewelry that is specifically made for engraving.

Making a purchase from Blue Nile comes with many benefits, including:

FAQ – Common Questions

Is Blue Nile reputable?

Yes, Blue Nile has one of the longest track records of any retailer selling online. They generally have excellent customer service and support and securely ship all merchandise.

Are Tiffany diamonds really better?

No, not necessarily. The truth is that Tiffany is just a brand name. The more important thing to consider is the GIA gemological rating of a diamond (the highest standard in the industry). While Tiffany can “say” their standards are higher, it’s impossible to verify this and is likely a marketing tactic.

Is Blue Nile actually cheaper?

In many cases, yes. Blue Nile also has a price match guarantee, meaning that if they aren’t the lowest, they will at least match a competitor.

Finale Take: Which is Better – Blue Nile or Tiffany?

Why I Prefer James Allen Personally, I love the James Allen 360 degree view customization options. If you want to customize the perfect ring, James Allen is THE best choice with the highest fidelity visuals. Ranked our #1 online jewelry retailer for 2020! View Collection and Deals Why I Prefer James Allen We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.

As you can see, each retailer has their own excellent qualities as well as drawbacks.

When it comes to online convenience, diamond education, price and benefits, Blue Nile is ahead of Tiffany & Co.

When it comes to the utmost quality and rarity of diamonds, diversity and inventory of jewelry and gifts, and jewelry strore physical shopping and designing, Tiffany out-ranks Blue Nile.

We hope this has allowed you to become better-informed and more confident in your engagement ring purchasing. To check out the latest selections of diamond rings and more, you can visit Blue Nile here.

My Bottom Line: While I prefer Blue Nile for having a better ONLINE customer experience, I actually have a different top pick. INSTEAD, my new favorite online retailer has to be James Allen here, with superior visual graphics (360 high-def), better prices, and consistently higher customer service.

Further Reading on Online Diamond Retailers

Sue Fox

Love You Tomorrow was founded by Sue Fox, a jewelry and wedding enthusiast from New York. Her father, Simon, was a jewelry appraiser, whose family had deep roots in the mining industry. Sue grew up schooled in the different properties of gems and metals, as well as in the care and appraisal of jewelry. She was most fascinated by how different gems, materials, cuts, and settings could be put together in endless combinations to make thousands of unique pieces of jewelry. Best of all, each piece was distinct in its purpose and design to match the personality of the wearer. Love You Tomorrow began as a passion project in 2016. This was around the time when many of Sue’s friends and family members were getting married. Knowing her expertise, they often sought out her advice on wedding and engagement rings. The blog started out as a place to house Sue’s now in-demand knowledge. Her first posts were buying guides for diamonds, roundups of her favorite ring recommendations around the web, and practical tips about choosing the right gemstone for you. It became apparent pretty quickly that the most common visitors to her blog were couples in the market for wedding and engagement rings. Since rings were only one item on an engaged couple’s to-do list, Sue also began to receive inquiries about how the perfect rings would fit into the rest of the whole wedding picture. Since then, Sue’s vision for the blog expanded to become a one-stop shop for other resources on weddings in general. Today, Love You Tomorrow is a wedding blog that features not just Sue’s expertise on wedding and engagement rings, but also insights from her “Wedding Party”, a team of wedding experts and enthusiasts who write guides, recommendations, and tips for happy couples looking to tie the knot. Sue is now currently based in Carmel-by-the-Sea on the Monterey Peninsula in California. She lives with her husband Jess, and their three dogs, Sleepy, Dopey, and Doc.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below