Agape Diamonds Review: Should You Shop Here?

Last Updated on

According to some statistics, as much as over eighty percent of engagement rings are diamonds, despite a recent trend towards diamond ring alternatives, including gemstones like sapphires, rubies, and morganite, and moissanite. But what many people don’t realize is that some of the popular engagement rings are not from natural diamonds, but from lab-grown diamonds, as is the philosophy at Agape Diamonds.

The trend towards lab-grown vs natural diamonds is not new, but it seems to be gaining momentum. In Silicon Valley, lab grown diamonds are seen as a way to cut back, or even eventually eliminate mining practices.

diamond ring

Diamond mining has been linked to a number of both ethical and environmental concerns. In Angola, for instance, careless and aggressive mining has led to deforestation and soil erosion. As is the case with places around the world, diamond mining has often also been tied to unfair or abusive labor practices, and even financing civil wars.

Fortunately, not all natural diamonds fall in this category. The Kimberley Process is a stamp on the best diamond sellers that their diamonds do not help support finance civil wars. Some companies, such as Brilliant Earth, also apply more standards to ensure better practices, including a commitment to local economies and humane labor practices, while Blue Nile adheres to responsible mining practices.

But there’s still plenty of other reasons many might opt for lab-grown over natural diamonds, and companies like Agape Diamonds are proving that these options can be just as appealing to many consumers. But what is Agape Diamonds, and is it a reputable place to buy diamonds or engagement rings from? In this review, we’ll investigate Agape Diamonds as a retailer, and see whether or not they’re a good option for finding diamonds online.

We’ll also discuss the intricacies of lab-grown vs natural diamonds.

What are natural diamonds, and where do they come from? 

Natural diamonds, as the name implies, occur naturally and must be mined for, as they are formed in subduction zones of Earth’s mantle.

Today, natural diamonds are mined in around twenty-five different countries, but Africa, Russia, and Canada account for as much as ninety percent of diamonds sold. Botswana, Angola, South Africa, and Congo account for fifty percent of market-ready diamonds.

What makes natural diamonds desirable?

One of the most desirable aspects of natural diamonds is simply the idea many like the concept of a natural diamond. However, there are other advantages to a natural diamond vs a lab grown one.

As a whole, natural diamonds:

  • Are more valuable
  • Have lower carbon emissions (lab-grown diamonds emit as many as three times carbon during the production process)
  • Are more supportive, when conflict free and ethically sourced, to local economies around the world.

What is a lab-grown diamond?

diamonds

Lab-grown diamonds are carefully grown in temperature-controlled labs in a way that mimics how natural diamonds develop. Lab-grown diamonds have identical physical and chemical components of natural diamonds and also look similar in appearance. This is not to be confused with diamond simulants, such as cubic zirconia, which mimick a diamond’s appearance but are not the same in terms of physical and chemical properties.

Lab-grown diamonds, compared with natural diamonds, are less valuable but have these advantages:

  • Are more affordable. Lab-grown diamonds cost about eighty to sixty percent of the cost of natural diamonds.
  • Are easier to get a hold of. Because lab-grown diamonds can be grown all over the world, you’ll have a wider selection.
  • Are conflict-free, while some diamonds are not.
  • Tend to have more even appearances and less blemishes. Natural diamonds have naturally occurring imperfections, may be uneven in color and clarity, and have surface-level infractions. Lab-grown diamonds, however, can and should be uniform and without defects, for a flawless appearance.
  • Cut quality ranges less; most lab-grown diamonds are very good to ideal, while natural diamonds can display poor cuts.

How popular are lab-grown diamonds?  

To be sure, lab-grown diamonds still have a while to catch up to the popularity of natural diamonds. Lab-grown diamonds, for now, make up a modest portion, estimated at under five percent of all diamond and diamond ring sales. Still, there are signs that may grow in the coming years and may play an important role in the years to come.

In fact, Paul Zimnisky, an industry expert interviewed by NPR, estimates that the now modest sales for lab-grown diamonds could rise from two billion dollars a year to fifteen billion over the next fifteen years which could be good news for a company like Agape Diamonds.

What’s the difference between lab-grown and synthetic diamonds? 

lab grown diamonds

For now, there’s a more popular alternative to natural diamonds: synthetic diamonds. Synthetic diamonds are far cheaper than lab-grown and natural diamonds and can easily be made and thus are readily available. The very best synthetic diamonds mimic the appearance of diamonds and are budget-friendly.

Compared with both lab-grown and natural diamonds, synthetic diamonds:

  • Are far cheaper. Synthetic diamonds can fit almost any budget.
  • Are less durable and hard. While lab grown diamonds are the same on the hardness scale as natural diamonds, synthetic tend to be softer and more prone to damage.

How do I know if a company like Agape Diamonds, which focuses on lab-grown diamonds, is a decent company? 

Shopping for diamonds online can have many benefits, including lower prices and greater variety. But shopping online can pose risks as well, especially for retailers that are solely online and don’t have a physical showroom. In order to determine whether or not Agape Diamonds is a good option, we’ll be looking at the following factors:

  • Contact information. While it’s perhaps not the most exciting way to start off, you should always make sure that the company has contact information, and, in the case of a company selling diamonds, the more the better. Look for a direct phone number, email address, and preferably some kind of physical address.

  • Customer policies. It’s also important understanding not only what diamonds the retailer sales, but the conditions that come with them. Keep your eye out for shipping policies, warranties, returns or exchanges, and how the company collects and uses your data. Some companies will also offer incentives, just as a discount for referring a friend, diamond upgrade programs, and price matching with competitors.

  • Site navigation. While not the very most important feature, a reputable company should have a fairly organized site. For your own shopping purposes, different sections should be neatly labeled and there should also be easy to use filters by characteristics, such as price, carat, color, clarity, metal type, and whatever else is applicable to the specific product.

  • Diamond sourcing. Normally, for natural diamonds, the ideal would be to select diamonds that are adhering to the Kimberley Process, which ensures that diamonds are not being used to finance civil wars. We might also look for other standards, including commitments to environmental and economic stability, fair labor practices, and ethical mining practices. For lab grown diamonds, we are looking information as to how and where the diamonds are grown.

    Ideally, we’d also like to see lab-grown diamonds that have been certified through a professional third party, just as the GIA institute, to ensure that they are indeed lab-grown diamonds and not simulants.

  • Selection and offerings. This section is perhaps the most subjective, in that it depends what you, as the customer, are looking for. More diamond and diamond rings, necklaces, earrings and other products is not always better. For this section, we’ll simply be looking at what you can expect to find, and pointing out limitations for different categories.

  • Pricing. Pricing can go both ways–while you, of course, want to find reasonably priced diamonds, cheaper isn’t always better. In terms of pricing, we’re simply looking for pricing that makes sense when you look at competitors and the overall market. We also want to look into pricing transparency, or how easy it is to determine the price.

  • Company accreditation and history. Not all e-commerce businesses are accredited through Better Business Bureau, but it’s a plus if they are. As far as company history, do they mention it at all on their site? Has the company been established for at least a few years, with a record of sales and few officially filed complaints?

  • Customer feedback. Finally, how much did customers find that the products delivered as advertised, both in terms of quality and overall service? It’s also important to note any consistent patterns in terms of complaints.

Is Agape Diamonds a good place to buy from? 

agape diamonds

Now onto our review of Agape Diamonds, where we’ll be investigating all of the features we’ve mentioned so far. We’ll start with first impressions. The first page is rather promotion heavy, featuring current sales, bestsellers, and a few featured collections.

Their claim is that they hope to create beautiful lab-grown diamonds that serve as an alternative to the ethical concerns with natural diamonds, but within the first lines of “About Us” there are a few problems with their claims. Let’s take a look at them.

What is the claim, and why is it concerning?

By and large, Agape Diamonds advertises as a company that sells lab-grown diamonds. As we’ve already discussed, lab-grown diamonds, while not the same as natural diamonds in every way, do share the same chemical and physical properties as natural diamonds. However, let’s take a look at the statement made by Agape Diamonds:

  • “In addition to the Agape Simulated Diamond, we offer Synthetic Diamonds, which are also known as Lab Grown Diamonds or Lab Created Diamonds.”
  • There are issues with this assertion for a few reasons. While lab-grown are synthetic diamonds, it quickly becomes clear that the marketing is, at best, messy, and at worst, misleading. As a company that touts itself as selling lab-grown diamonds, the reality is, while they do sell lab-grown diamonds, they also sell a large collection of diamond simulants, which is very different in terms of value and physical and chemical properties.
  • The Federal Trade Commission seems to agree. In April 2019, Agape Diamonds was one of eight companies sent a letter warning against false claims. In the case of Agape and other places selling simulants, they were warned to “avoid describing their products in a way that may falsely imply that they have the same optical, physical, and chemical properties of mined diamonds.” The web address, diamondslabcreated.com, which Agape diamonds uses was part of what they pointed to as misleading.

Is there any contact information for Agape Diamonds?

agape ring

Agape Diamonds provides two main ways to contact, either through a phone line or a web inquiry form. They do also have a physical address linked to their showroom in Tampa, Florida.

What customer and general policies does Agape Diamonds have? 

  • All jewellery comes with a lifetime warranty against any manufacturing defects but does not cover loss or theft. In addition, if any repairs or work is done on jewelry by someone else, the lifetime warranty is void. It also cannot be transferred to someone else.
  • You have the option to have your jewelry serviced. Agape Diamonds recommends you do this every year, though it is unclear is this is free or if there are any additional costs involved.
  • You may return or exchange any purchases within thirty days. Items must be in new, unworn condition with receipts in order to be accepted.
  • At first glance, if you read too quickly, it sounds as if Agape Diamonds does not share any information with third parties. However, if you read more closely, you’ll notice that they include the term “any non-related” information. At best guess, this means they do in fact share basic information for marketing purposes. While this is not considered unusual, once again this feels like slightly misleading wording on Agape Diamond’s parts.
  • Financing is available; you can opt for three, six or twelve-month payments.

How easy is it to navigate, and shop on Agape Diamonds?

Agape Diamonds features an easy enough to use, if not advanced interface. At the top of the webpage, you can peruse tabs for the main categories of products they sell. Scroll down on the home page and you’ll come across current deals and bestsellers. At the very bottom of the home page, you’ll find a link to information about the company and company policies.

Within each product section, options are a bit more limited. There are sections for the type of rings, for instance, but within those, you can only filter by price point or position. Overall, the search features are not nearly as user-friendly as some competing sites.

What products are sold? 

agape wedding bands

Of course, what you’re probably wondering most is what kind of products you can purchase from Agape Diamonds. Agape Diamonds sells engagement rings, earrings, pendants, bracelets, and loose stones.

Engagement Rings

Engagement rings fall under several categories: designer, wedding sets, solitaires, three-stone, Tiffany solitaires, cathedral-style solitaires, regular cathedral, and trio wedding sets.

  • For every engagement ring, you are able to select your desired metal type, which normally comes in 14K white or yellow gold. Something a bit misleading is that you’ll find costs add up quickly if you use the drop-down menu to select 18K gold or platinum, which can easily add several hundred dollars or more to the listed price.
  • It seems two and three-carat sizes are common, but you only see the carat size after clicking on the item; there is no way to filter or sort by carat.
  • As to the designer rings, it is unclear as to what makes the designer. Prices run around one thousand dollars to fourteen hundred dollars at regular price, which is quite inexpensive. Every engagement ring tells you the cut and style, but when you look at the details, you’ll see it’s not a natural or a lab-grown diamond.
  • In fact, most, if not all the engagement rings offered feature simulated diamonds, which is not the same quality as a synthetic diamond. You have to read closely under product information to see this information.

Earrings

  • Earrings fall under studs, halos, or colored earrings. There are just six stud earrings to choose from, and all have a base price of a little under five hundred dollars. Princess, radiant, Asscher, cushion and oval cuts are available for simulated diamonds.
  • For Halo cut, carats fall from one to five carats, and you’ll get more or less the same options you saw with studs and metal options like what you saw with engagement rings.
  • Colored earrings are available in a variety of cuts and styles. Double tier halo, oval, and milgrain are available, and all are available in white, emerald, ruby, topaz and citrine colors, but note these too are not actual gemstones. Expect to pay five hundred to around a thousand dollars for earrings; they are not that different from the prices of engagement rings.

Bracelets

Bracelets fall under a single category, which is designer tennis bracelets. There are just four option, ranging in price from about one thousand to thirteen hundred dollars when not on sale. Round and princess cut are available, in 14K white gold.

Loose Stones

  • Loose stones are the only category you’ll find anything beyond simulated diamonds and gems. Here, at least we can appreciate that it’s immediate transparent when you’re shopping for simulant, lab-grown, or natural diamonds.
  • Simulant diamonds are all priced at one hundred and twenty dollars normally and available in oval, round, princess, cushion, and marquise cuts.
  • Natural diamonds are priced at around nine thousand dollars, for a one carat round cut, to forty thousand dollars for a two-carat round cut. You will get information about the diamond grade, cut symmetry, polish, and every natural cut diamond comes with AGS or GIA certification, which is a big step up from what we’ve seen so far. That said, the collection is quite limited. There is no information about the standards or origin where these diamonds are sourced, either.
  • Lab-grown diamonds are now available only by request, apparently due to waiting lists and limited supply, which is quite strange, especially given that so much of Agape Diamond’s marketing is geared towards lab-grown diamonds (when in reality most are simulants).

What is the overall pricing like?

necklace

We’ve already mentioned price ranges for nearly every category, but let’s look at pricing as a whole. It may just be a coincidence, but nearly every item is currently on sale, which makes the sale sections arbitrary.

It’s unclear whether this is a special, limited occurrence or if it’s a marketing ploy. Pricing mostly, for engagement rings, does not seem unreasonable, but keep in mind that you are buying stimulants, as opposed to natural or lab-grown diamonds. It does not appear to be the best value.

Is the company accredited?

Agape Diamonds has been accredited by the Better Business Bureau for eight years, with an A-plus rating, which is quite interesting. Filed complaints include some issues with shipping and returns, as well as customers upset they did not understand they were buying cubic zirconia. There were also reports of stones falling out of engagement rings; however, these did not compromise a large number of complaints. Outside of Agape Diamond’s own website, it’s quite hard to find any reviews at all.

Do we recommend Agape Diamonds?

In many of our reviews of online diamond and gemstone sellers, there is no one easy answer, but that is not the case here. By and large, with a lack of selections, no customization, poor search filters, and, worse of all, highly misleading marketing, we cannot recommend you shop Agape Diamonds.

The fact of the matter is that you simply have far superior options. If you are looking for cubic zirconia, that is perfectly fine, but the company needs to be transparent as to what is being sold. Customer service options too are a bit vague, and lack of reviews and customer complaints, despite accreditation overall mean that until or unless Agape Diamonds changes its model, we won’t be recommending you shop there.

Are there any viable alternatives to Agape Diamonds?

brilliant earth diamond

As we’ve already mentioned, the good news is that there are alternatives, whether you’re looking for lab-grown or natural diamonds or simulants.

  • Brilliant Earth and Blue Nile are both excellent sources for ethically sourced, both natural and lab grown diamonds and diamond accessories. They also have decent customer reviews.
  • Ritani is another excellent diamond seller, boasting some of the highest customer ratings in the industry. They also offer some more affordable prices, compared with competitors.
  • Whiteflash is another source for diamonds that offers designer collections, an easy to navigate site, and one of their collections, called the Dreams of Africa, goes towards helping support impoverished children in African countries.
  • Brian Gavin offers excellent service in terms of customizing diamond and gemstone engagement rings and also offers several lines of in house designers.

Recommended Reads:

  • Whenever you are having doubts about whether to purchase a diamond ring or moissanite, we have an article ready for you so you can see what would better fit your style, budget, and preference.
  • Your ring doesn’t have to be just white, so here check our comparison between Moissanite vs Cubic Zirconia, in which colors they come, and what would be a better option for you.
Erin Jamieson

Erin has always loved wedding-related planning and fashion, and regularly follows bridal fashion in the news. She has also worked for a bridal boutique and is passionate about helping couples plan and budget so they can enjoy their wedding day with as little stress as possible. She is an accomplished writer who writes on many subjects, but she has a special place in her heart for new brides and is here to make their day extra special with great recommendations and ideas you can't find anywhere else. 

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below